Poll Two - Individual Rankings - January 9, 2024
| Wt | Ranking | Name | School |
| 125 | 1 | Ane'e Vigil | Clackamas |
| 2 | Bridger Ricks | Western Wyoming | |
| 3 | Elijah Cater | North Idaho | |
| 4 | Joe Petrone | Nassau | |
| 5 | Kaden Spragis | Pratt | |
| 6 | Trentin Walker | Iowa Central | |
| 7 | Isaac Gibbs | Indian Hills | |
| 8 | RJ Jones | Carl Albert | |
| 9 | Andre Giurini | Triton | |
| 10 | Jordan Simpson | SW Michigan | |
| 133 | 1 | Cody Phelps | Western Wyoming |
| 2 | Mauro Michel | Southwestern Oregon | |
| 3 | Anthony Schickel | Triton | |
| 4 | Paul Ruff | Iowa Western | |
| 5 | Corban Zugelder | Labette | |
| 6 | Arojae Hart | Indian Hills | |
| 7 | Zach Lopez | North Idaho | |
| 8 | Tim Lopez | Clackamas | |
| 9 | Tyson Wilson | Rochester | |
| 10 | Lance Olberding | Southeastern NE | |
| 141 | 1 | Easton Taylor | Pratt |
| 2 | Malachi Bordovsky | Iowa Western | |
| 3 | Isaac Church | NIACC | |
| 4 | Cole Holien | Ridgewater | |
| 5 | River Wardle | Western Wyoming | |
| 6 | Reggie Raiz | Clackamas | |
| 7 | Hunter Bidelman | North Idaho | |
| 8 | Marcus Terry | NE Oklahoma | |
| 9 | Ashton Hayhurst | Triton | |
| 10 | Cooper Evans | Carl Albert | |
| 149 | 1 | Matt Sarbo | Iowa Central |
| 2 | Chris Lopez | Western Wyoming | |
| 3 | Jaden Two Lance | Carl Albert | |
| 4 | Gabe Maki | Pratt | |
| 5 | Caleb Nadig | Northwest Wyoming | |
| 6 | Dante Oliverio | Clackamas | |
| 7 | Xzavier Suess | St. Clair | |
| 8 | Kolton Malone | Iowa Western | |
| 9 | Cohen Wiste | Rochester | |
| 10 | Anthony Bitner | Triton | |
| 157 | 1 | Kris Ketchum | Nassau |
| 2 | Tristan Stafford | Western Wyoming | |
| 3 | Manny Oliver | Morton | |
| 4 | Michael Myers | Iowa Central | |
| 5 | Gavin Gust | Rochester | |
| 6 | Davion King | Labette | |
| 7 | Channing Warner | Northeastern JC | |
| 8 | Porter Craig | North Idaho | |
| 9 | Jackson Wilkins | NE Oklahoma | |
| 10 | Job Lee | NW Kansas Tech | |
| 165 | 1 | Cayleb Atkins | Pratt |
| 2 | Cole Price | Iowa Western | |
| 3 | Rocky Raby | Clackamas | |
| 4 | Jayden Luttrell | Western Wyoming | |
| 5 | Connor Svatner | Triton | |
| 6 | Justice Compton | NE Oklahoma | |
| 7 | Travis Waldner | North Idaho | |
| 8 | Noah Smith | Carl Albert | |
| 9 | Peyton Asbury | Indian Hills | |
| 10 | Hunter Heath | SW Michigan | |
| 174 | 1 | Otgonbayar Batsuri | NW Kansas Tech |
| 2 | Paul Ortiz | Clackamas | |
| 3 | Mustafa Salimi | Triton | |
| 4 | Will Harmon | Western Wyoming | |
| 5 | Garrett Davis | Labette | |
| 6 | Alden Cohen | Harper | |
| 7 | Paul Kadlec | Joliet | |
| 8 | Jaquan East | Indian Hills | |
| 9 | Lawrence Rosario | Iowa Central | |
| 10 | Conan Northwind | North Idaho | |
| 184 | 1 | Darion Johnson | Western Wyoming |
| 2 | Aziz Fayzullaev | Northwest Wyoming | |
| 3 | Blake Jouret | Pratt | |
| 4 | Lazaro Crespo | NW Kansas Tech | |
| 5 | Noah Poe-Hatten | North Idaho | |
| 6 | Tye Frnka | NE Oklahoma | |
| 7 | Jessey Colas | NIACC | |
| 8 | Brent Greenfield | Ellsworth | |
| 9 | Darion Thompson | Indian Hills | |
| 10 | Trystin Irvin | Iowa Central | |
| 197 | 1 | Geoff Freeman | NE Oklahoma |
| 2 | Matthew Marcum | Labette | |
| 3 | Luke MacDonald | Iowa Western | |
| 4 | Bradley Whitwright | North Idaho | |
| 5 | Wesley Reeves | Western Wyoming | |
| 6 | Gavin Dodge | NW Kansas Tech | |
| 7 | Hunter Hall | Carl Albert | |
| 8 | Ghee Rachal | Triton | |
| 9 | Jake Navarro | Henry Ford | |
| 10 | Ansel Cervantes | Indian Hills | |
| HWT | 1 | Cody Pinkerton | Northwest Wyoming |
| 2 | Dmarian Lopez | Western Wyoming | |
| 3 | CJ Carter | Iowa Western | |
| 4 | Tucker Hugg | Ridgewater | |
| 5 | Oleg Simakov | Harper | |
| 6 | Shane Edwards | SW Michigan | |
| 7 | Rylee Creasey | Snow | |
| 8 | Tominiko Takafua | North Idaho | |
| 9 | Riley Butt | Northeastern JC | |
| 10 | DJ Moehring | Iowa Central |