All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Football Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Kai Locksley | Iowa Western | 6-4 | 205 | So. | |
| RB | Greg Bell | Arizona Western | 6-0 | 190 | So. | |
| RB | Mekhi Sargent | Iowa Western | 5-11 | 215 | Fr. | |
| WR | Malik Williams | Northland (MN) | 5-8 | 165 | So. | |
| WR | Terry Williams | Itawamba (MS) | 5-10 | 175 | So. | |
| TE | Nigel Kilby | Garden City (KS) | 6-8 | 245 | So. | |
| OL | Chancelor House | Iowa Western | 6-5 | 322 | So. | |
| OL | Jahmir Johnson | Arizona Western | 6-5 | 290 | Fr. | |
| OL | Levon Livingston | Navarro (TX) | 6-8 | 275 | So. | |
| OL | Matt Martin | Trinity Valley (TX) | 6-2 | 285 | Fr. | |
| OL | Anthony McKinney | Iowa Western | 6-7 | 340 | So. | |
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Chester Graves | Iowa Western | 6-5 | 240 | Fr. | |
| DL | Antwuan Jackson Jr. | Blinn (TX) | 6-3 | 300 | Fr. | |
| DL | Hal Northern | Northwest Mississippi | 6-2 | 285 | So. | |
| DL | Ramero Rock | Georgia Military | 6-1 | 235 | So. | |
| LB | Troy Burnett | Kilgore (TX) | 6-0 | 225 | So. | |
| LB | Vernon Dasher | Coffeyville (KS) | 6-3 | 210 | So. | |
| LB | Connor Taylor | Snow (UT) | 6-1 | 235 | So. | |
| DB | Benjie Franklin | Navarro (TX) | 6-0 | 180 | So. | |
| DB | Le'Vonte Larry | Iowa Central | 5-11 | 185 | Fr. | |
| DB | Duke Upshaw | East Mississippi | 6-0 | 185 | So. | |
| DB | Dorian Williams | Independence (KS) | 5-11 | 195 | So. | |
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Alfredo Marquez | Scottsdale (AZ) | 6-1 | 224 | Fr. | |
| P | Tyreke Williams | Iowa Central | 6-1 | 212 | Fr. | |
| RS | Leon Morgan | Snow (UT) | 5-9 | 150 | Fr. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Dan Ellington | Itawamba (MS) | 6-2 | 195 | So. | |
| RB | Darwin Thompson | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 5-8 | 195 | So. | |
| RB | DeAndre Torrey | Mississippi Gulf Coast | 5-10 | 195 | Fr. | |
| WR | Edward Morgan Jr. | ASA Brooklyn (NY) | 6-0 | 185 | Fr. | |
| WR | Devin Neal | Scottsdale (AZ) | 6-0 | 170 | Fr. | |
| TE | Dominick Wood-Anderson | Arizona Western | 6-6 | 255 | So. | |
| OL | Steven Bailey | Glendale (AZ) | 6-3 | 300 | So. | |
| OL | Michael Davis | Highland (KS) | 6-5 | 325 | So. | |
| OL | Aaron Dowdell | Georgia Military | 6-4 | 330 | Fr. | |
| OL | David Harris | Monroe (NY) | 6-3 | 335 | So. | |
| OL | Damien Lewis | Northwest Mississippi | 6-3 | 320 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSEhttp://www.njcaa.org/sports/fball/2017-18/players/hakiwoodsg6w4 | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Issac Fotu | Snow (UT) | 6-2 | 225 | Fr. | |
| DL | Emmit Gooden | Independence (KS) | 6-4 | 320 | So. | |
| DL | Jaicorious Johnson | ASA Brooklyn (NY) | 6-1 | 285 | So. | |
| DL | Ivin White Jr. | Hinds (MS) | 6-2 | 240 | Fr. | |
| LB | Dillon Hall | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 6-1 | 220 | So. | |
| LB | Brandon Perce | Rochester (MN) | 6-0 | 215 | So. | |
| LB | Roy Yancey | Arizona Western | 6-2 | 215 | So. | |
| DB | Vonte Davis | Blinn (TX) | 6-2 | 190 | Fr. | |
| DB | Ky'el Hemby | Iowa Western | 6-1 | 195 | Fr. | |
| DB | Malik Wilder | Nassau (NY) | 5-10 | 190 | So. | |
| DB | Haki Woods | Pima (AZ) | 6-3 | 192 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Angel Sevier | Trinity Valley (TX) | 5-9 | 200 | Fr. | |
| P | John Bowers | Pima (AZ) | 6-0 | 200 | So. | |
| RS | Rodney Murphy | Dodge City (KS) | 5-11 | 180 | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Shannon Patrick | Northland (MN) | 6-2 | 200 | So. | |
| RB | DeAndre Cook | Navarro (TX) | 5-10 | 190 | So. | |
| RB | D'Arman Notoa | Snow (UT) | 5-11 | 209 | Fr. | |
| WR | Sonnie Richardson | Mesa (AZ) | 5-9 | 183 | So. | |
| WR | Ben Rooney | Ellsworth (IA) | 5-9 | 165 | So. | |
| TE | Dakari Highsmith | Northland (MN) | 5-10 | 185 | So. | |
| OL | Raekwon Allen | Georgia Military | 6-3 | 325 | So. | |
| OL | Noah Banks | Iowa Western | 6-8 | 315 | So. | |
| OL | Tarik Johnson | Erie (NY) | 6-4 | 298 | So. | |
| OL | James Newman | Dakota (ND) | 6-1 | 300 | So. | |
| OL | Elbert Watson | Copiah-Lincoln (MS) | 6-6 | 315 | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Tim Butcher | Iowa Central | 6-2 | 298 | So. | |
| DL | Amadou Fofana | Highland (KS) | 6-5 | 270 | So. | |
| DL | Tavon Joseph | Nassau (NY) | 6-3 | 215 | Fr. | |
| DL | Chris Jules | Scottsdale (AZ) | 6-1 | 235 | So. | |
| LB | Cecil Cherry | Coahoma (MS) | 6-2 | 225 | So. | |
| LB | Byron Galvin | Hinds (MS) | 5-11 | 200 | So. | |
| LB | Jeremiah Hill | Highland (KS) | 6-0 | 210 | So. | |
| DB | Bryce Beekman | Arizona Western | 6-4 | 185 | Fr. | |
| DB | Adrien Cross | Hutchinson (KS) | 5-10 | 192 | So. | |
| DB | Jordan Jones | Nassau (NY) | 6-0 | 175 | Fr. | |
| DB | John McClure | Ridgewater (MN) | 6-2 | 195 | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Taylor Crabtree | East Mississippi | 5-8 | 170 | So. | |
| P | Cooper Lee | Coffeyville (KS) | 6-1 | 190 | So. | |
| RS | Vincent Perry | Iowa Western | 5-11 | 180 | So. | |
